Dr. Christian Barnard, the surgeon who removed the heart from a dead woman and put it in the body of a sick man, is firm in defending the ethics of the historic operation. "The purpose of this heart transplant," he told a news conference Thursday, "was not to do a heart transplant but to cure a sick man. The only way to do it was by the transplant. So I don't see any ethical question. I just tried to cure a sick man." Barnard, 45, a restless man who likes to joke with the press in both English and Afrikaans about the operation, suddenly turned quiet and measured in his comments when asked about criticism from a few surgeons in the United States. Reports reaching here have quoted Dr. Andre Cournard of Columbia University, a Nobel Prize winner, as saying, "Merely demonstrating that it is technically feasible to transplant a heart from one human to another is not in my opinion ethically a reason to proceed..."
Dr. Christian Barnard, the surgeon who removed the heart from a dead woman and put it in the body of a sick man, is firm in defending the ethics of the historic operation. "The purpose of this heart transplant," he told a news conference Thursday, "was not to do a heart transplant but to cure a sick man. The only way to do it was by the transplant. So I don't see any ethical question. I just tried to cure a sick man." Barnard, 45, a restless man who likes to joke with the press in both English and Afrikaans about the operation, suddenly turned quiet and measured in his comments when asked about criticism from a few surgeons in the United States. Reports reaching here have quoted Dr. Andre Cournard of Columbia University, a Nobel Prize winner, as saying, "Merely demonstrating that it is technically feasible to transplant a heart from one human to another is not in my opinion ethically a reason to proceed..."
Read more...Read more...